Insurance Automation Strategy: What Should Agencies and Brokerages Automate First?

09 Nov

Where to Start with Insurance Automation

Insurance agencies and brokerages have more automation options than ever.

Renewal reminders can run automatically. Quote follow-ups can be triggered when prospects do not respond. Billing reminders can be sent without someone checking a spreadsheet. Client check-ins, reviews, cross-sell opportunities and cancellation follow-ups can all become structured workflows.

But that creates a new problem: What should you automate first?

A successful insurance automation strategy is not about automating the largest possible number of tasks. It is about identifying the repetitive processes consuming the most time, understanding where automation can improve consistency, and keeping people involved when professional judgement matters.

That distinction is becoming increasingly important.

In the US, 46% of independent insurance agencies reported using AI in 2026, up from only 15% in 2024. Yet the biggest technology challenge for agencies remains dealing with multiple carrier interfaces.

In the UK, Aviva’s 2025 Broker Barometer found that 85% of brokers were interested or very interested in improving operations through digital or automated processes. By 2026, 46% identified investment in digital technology and AI as a priority.

Technology adoption is accelerating. The harder question is deciding where it actually belongs.

Quick Answer: What Should Insurance Agencies and Brokerages Automate First?

Start with workflows that are:

Frequent
Repetitive
Time-sensitive
Based on reliable policy or client data
Easy to define with clear rules
Costly when delayed or missed
Measurable after automation

For many insurance businesses, that makes these strong first candidates:

Renewal communication and follow-ups
Quote follow-ups
Billing and payment reminders
Client onboarding
Routine client communication and check-ins
Cross-sell opportunities
Reviews, surveys and referrals
Cancellation and lost-client follow-up
Routine claims communication

Processes involving complex advice, sensitive circumstances, unusual risks or significant professional judgement should remain human-led.

The principle is simple: Automate predictable work. Keep judgement human.

What Is an Insurance Automation Strategy?

An insurance automation strategy is a structured plan for deciding which insurance processes should be automated, in what order, how automation connects with existing systems, and where employees should remain involved. That is different from simply purchasing automation software.

Without a strategy, insurance brokerage or agency can end up with:

Too many disconnected tools
Automations employees do not trust
Duplicate client data
Irrelevant communication
Processes that still require manual checking
Automation applied to workflows that were poorly designed in the first place

A better approach begins with the business process, not the technology. Ask: Where is our team spending time repeatedly doing something that follows a predictable pattern?

That is where an insurance automation strategy starts.

Why Insurance Automation Strategy Matters More in 2027

Insurance businesses are not short of technology. They are short of connected technology that removes actual work.

Applied Systems’ 2026 Agency-Carrier Connectivity Survey of 702 US independent agents found that 74% identified re-keying information into multiple carrier portals as their top workflow pain point.

Even more striking, 98% of agents said they re-key information that already exists in their AMS. Commercial submission automation was the number one capability agents wanted from carriers, cited by 79%.

This is not a new problem. In Applied’s 2025 research, 72% of agents already identified the commercial submission process as the area where they most wanted greater insurance automation.

The lesson is important. The value of automation is not simply that software can perform a task.

The value comes from removing duplicate work, unnecessary handoffs and repetitive actions from processes employees already perform every day.

The PathwayPort Insurance Automation Priority Framework

Before automating a workflow, score it across five areas.

1. Frequency

How often does the process happen?

A task repeated hundreds or thousands of times per year usually has greater automation potential than something performed several times annually.

Ask:

How many renewals do we process?
How many quote follow-ups do employees send?
How many payment reminders are manually prepared?
How many clients need routine check-ins?

The greater the volume, the greater the potential impact. Learn what are the top 10 insurance workflows to automate.

2. Manual Effort

How much employee time does each occurrence require? A five-minute activity may appear insignificant.

But if employees repeat it 2,000 times annually, that is more than 166 hours of work. Small repetitive tasks become large operational costs when multiplied across an entire book of business.

3. Time Sensitivity

What happens if someone forgets? A missed internal administrative task may have little immediate impact. A missed renewal follow-up, unanswered quote or overdue payment reminder can affect client experience, revenue or retention.

The greater the cost of delay, the stronger the case for automation.

4. Data Readiness

Can the workflow start from information already stored in your AMS or BMS?

Examples include:

Renewal date
Policy status
Effective date
Policy type
Client type
Premium
Billing status
Quote status
Carrier
Branch
Existing policies

The stronger the underlying data, the easier it becomes to create relevant automation. If employees first need to manually build spreadsheets before the automation can run, the underlying process may need improvement first.

5. Human Judgement

Does the next step require advice or professional interpretation?

This is the most important checkpoint.

A system can trigger a reminder because a renewal is approaching.
A system can identify that information is missing.
A system can highlight that a policy has changed.

But deciding whether coverage is appropriate for a particular client may require a broker or agent. The higher the level of judgement, the more automation should support the employee rather than replace the decision.

How to Score Your Automation Opportunities

Give each workflow a score from 1 to 5 for:

Factor	1	5
Frequency	Rare	Very frequent
Manual effort	Minimal	Significant
Time sensitivity	Low	Critical
Data readiness	Poor	Strong
Business impact	Limited	High

Then review the level of professional judgement separately.

20–25 points

Strong candidate to automate first

15–19 points

Good automation candidate, usually with human checkpoints

10–14 points

Improve or standardise the process before automating

Below 10

Probably not an automation priority yet

One rule should override the score:

If the process requires significant professional judgement, automate the administrative steps around it rather than the decision itself.

1. Start with Insurance Renewals

For many established agencies and brokerages, renewals should be near the top of the automation priority list.

Renewal process is:

Frequent
Predictable
Time-sensitive
Data-driven
Repetitive
Directly connected with client retention

A traditional renewal process can require employees to identify upcoming renewals, prepare lists, request information, chase responses, check policy information and repeatedly update systems. Much of that work follows predictable rules.

What Can Be Automated in a Renewal Workflow?

Automation can:

Identify policies approaching renewal.
Start communication at a predefined point.
Request updated information.
Send reminders when clients do not respond.
Create internal activities.
Escalate unresponsive accounts.
Segment workflows by client or policy type.
Trigger post-renewal communication.
Record activities back into connected systems where supported.

The broker or agent remains responsible for advice, exceptions and complex conversations. The objective is not to automate the relationship.

It is to ensure employees reach the conversation with less administrative work still waiting to be completed.

2. Automate Quote Follow-Ups

A prospect receives a quote. Then what?

In many insurance brokerages and agencies, the answer depends on who created it. One producer calls the next morning. Another follows up after three days. Someone else remembers when they see the quote again a week later. Automation can create consistency.

A simple workflow could look like:

Quote created → first follow-up → no response → reminder → no response → employee activity

The system handles the predictable sequence. The producer handles the conversation. This is an important distinction because speed should not require removing people from the process.

In the Big “I” 2026 Agency Universe Study, 86% of agencies said they still prefer customer service to take place through the agency by phone or other non-online methods.

Insurance remains relationship-driven. Insurance automation should make those relationships easier to manage consistently.

3. Automate Billing and Payment Reminders

Payment chasing is another strong automation candidate because it combines repetition with time sensitivity.

Instead of employees repeatedly reviewing accounts and sending similar reminders, a workflow can:

Detect the relevant billing status.
Trigger the appropriate communication.
Send a follow-up if necessary.
Notify the responsible employee if the issue remains unresolved.
Stop the sequence when the underlying status changes.

The key is the final step. Good automation does not simply send messages. It responds when the situation changes.

That requires insurance automation to work with accurate policy and client information rather than relying on outdated lists.

4. Automate Client Onboarding

The first interactions after someone becomes a client can shape their perception of the agency or brokerage.

Yet onboarding often varies depending on employee workload.

One client receives a detailed welcome.
Another receives only the documents required to get started.
A third may not hear from the brokerage again until renewal.
A structured onboarding workflow can create a consistent starting point.

For example:

Policy becomes effective → welcome communication → useful information → service expectations → check-in

The routine communication runs automatically. The relationship remains personal.

5. Automate Routine Client Communication

Many insurance businesses think about automation primarily in terms of email. That is too narrow.

The more important question is: What event should cause communication to happen?

Generic marketing automation might say: Send this message next Tuesday.

Insurance-specific automation can say: Send this because something changed in the client’s insurance journey.

That event might be:

A renewal approaching
A policy becoming effective
A quote being created
A payment requiring attention
A client reaching a defined check-in point
A policy cancellation
A relevant cross-sell opportunity

This is where insurance automation becomes much more useful than simply scheduling campaigns.

6. Automate Client Check-Ins

Renewal should not be the only time an agency speaks with a client. Client circumstances can change throughout the policy period.

For personal lines, that could include:

Vehicles
Property
Household circumstances
Contact information
New assets

For commercial clients:

Employees
Locations
Equipment
Operations
Revenue
Cyber exposure
Fleet changes

Automated check-ins can create an opportunity to identify those changes earlier. The automation does not make a coverage recommendation. It helps start the conversation at the right time.

7. Automate Cross-Sell Identification

Cross-selling should not mean sending the same promotional message to every client. A better insurance automation strategy uses existing information to identify where a relevant conversation may exist.

For example:

A client has home insurance but no auto policy recorded.
A commercial customer holds several policies but does not have a particular coverage type recorded.
Automation can identify the segment and trigger either:
Relevant client communication, or
An internal activity for the producer

The purpose is not to maximise the number of sales messages. It is to help employees identify opportunities they may otherwise overlook.

8. Automate Reviews, Feedback and Referrals

A completed interaction can create another useful workflow.

After an appropriate client experience, automation can trigger:

A satisfaction survey
An NPS® survey
A Google review request
A referral request

An internal follow-up after negative feedback. But sending the survey should not be considered the end of the process. The response matters.

For example:

Positive feedback → appropriate review request

Negative feedback → internal notification → employee follow-up

That is the difference between automating a message and automating a useful workflow.

9. Automate Policy Cancellation Follow-Up

A cancelled policy does not necessarily mean a lost client.

Clients may:

Remove one policy while keeping others.
No longer require a particular type of coverage.
Move one policy elsewhere.
Leave because of price.
Leave because of service.
Have another reason entirely.

Instead of immediately treating every cancellation as lost business, a workflow can help determine what happened.

For example:

Cancellation identified → client status checked → follow-up triggered → reason captured → appropriate next action

This can help the brokerage distinguish a policy-level change from a relationship-level loss. It can also create better information for future retention efforts.

What Should Insurance Agencies and Brokerages NOT Automate First?

Not every inefficient task should immediately become an automated task. Some processes should remain primarily human-led.

Be cautious with:

Complex coverage recommendations
Unusual risks
Negotiations
Sensitive complaints
Vulnerable client circumstances
Coverage disputes
Complex claims conversations
Situations requiring significant professional judgement

Insurance automation can still support these processes.

For example, it can:

Gather information
Create an activity
Alert an employee
Prepare relevant data
Schedule a follow-up
Record what happened

But the final decision remains with the professional.

UK Brokers: Automation Must Support Consumer Understanding

UK brokerages should consider another factor when building their insurance automation strategy: communication quality and timing.

The FCA’s March 2026 Consumer Understanding review says firms should provide customers with the information they need at the right time, using clear and accessible communication.

The FCA also highlights communication testing, monitoring and governance as part of a coherent end-to-end process. It specifically notes the value of using information throughout the customer journey rather than treating individual communications in isolation. This has important implications for insurance automation.

A successful workflow should not be measured only by:

“Was the email sent?”

It should also consider:

Was the communication relevant?
Was the timing appropriate?
Did the customer understand what they needed to do?
Did the process identify customers requiring additional support?
Was the next action clear?
Can the brokerage monitor the outcome?

For UK brokerages, insurance automation should therefore support a better customer journey, not simply higher message volume.

US Agencies: Start with Connectivity, Not Another Standalone Tool

For US agencies, one of the biggest automation opportunities is reducing the number of disconnected processes around the AMS.

The 2026 Ivans connectivity research found that 98% of agents re-key information that already exists in their AMS.

That is a useful warning. Adding another standalone system that employees have to update manually may create more work rather than less.

A better insurance automation strategy asks: Can the workflow use information already available in the management system?

And: Can actions generated by the automation become part of the existing client record?

The ideal model is closer to:

AMS/BMS data → workflow trigger → automated action → client or employee response → activity recorded

rather than:

AMS/BMS → spreadsheet → manual upload → campaign → another spreadsheet

Your AMS or BMS Should Remain at the Centre

Automation does not require replacing your insurance management system. Your AMS or BMS already contains much of the information automation needs.

That information can determine:

Who enters a workflow
When communication begins
Which message is relevant
When an employee needs to intervene
When automation should stop

This matters because insurance workflows are not generic campaigns.

A renewal workflow depends on renewal information.
A billing workflow depends on billing information.
A cancellation workflow depends on policy status.
A cross-sell workflow depends on what the client already holds.

The stronger the connection between insurance data and automation, the more relevant the resulting action can become.

How to Build an Insurance Automation Strategy in 90 Days

You do not need to automate the entire client lifecycle at once. A more practical approach is to prove value with one process.

Days 1–30: Find the Work

Identify repetitive workflows. Talk to employees who actually perform them.

Document:

Number of cases each month
Average time per case
Number of manual touchpoints
Systems involved
Common delays
Common errors

Points requiring professional judgement Then use the Insurance Automation Priority Framework to rank them.

Days 31–60: Automate One Workflow

Choose one high-scoring process.

Define: Trigger → Actions → Exceptions → Human intervention → Completion

For example:

Renewal approaching → information request → reminder → no response → account manager activity

Do not automate ten processes simultaneously. Learn from one.

Days 61–90: Measure and Improve

Compare the new process with your baseline.

Look at:

Time spent
Number of manual activities
Response rates
Uncompleted tasks
Client engagement
Employee adoption
Revenue or retention outcomes where relevant

Then improve the workflow before expanding automation elsewhere.

How to Measure Insurance Automation Strategy ROI

Insurance automation should create measurable operational improvements. A good place to start is time saved.

Estimated monthly administrative hours saved:

Number of cases × minutes saved per case ÷ 60

For example:

1,000 activities × 6 minutes saved ÷ 60 = 100 hours saved

But time saved is only one measure of value.

Depending on the workflow, agencies and brokerages can also track:

Renewal response rate
Renewal or retention rate
Quote follow-up completion
Quote conversion rate
Outstanding billing follow-ups
Client engagement
Cross-sell opportunities identified
Review volume
Client feedback
Number of overdue activities

The metric should match the problem the automation was introduced to solve.

If renewals were automated because employees were spending too much time chasing information, measure the reduction in manual follow-ups and administrative time.

If quote follow-up was automated because prospects were being missed, measure follow-up completion and quote conversion.

Do not measure automation success only by the number of messages sent or workflows completed. Measure what changed as a result.

What Does a Good Insurance Automation Strategy Look Like?

A strong strategy usually has five characteristics.

It starts with a business problem

Not a software feature.

It uses insurance data

Triggers come from real policy, client or workflow information where possible.

It creates exceptions for people

Employees are brought in when their expertise is valuable.

It connects with existing systems

Automation should reduce duplicate work rather than create another isolated database.

It can be measured

The agency and brokerage know what success looks like before the workflow launches.

How PathwayPort Supports an Insurance Automation Strategy

PathwayPort helps insurance agencies and brokerages automate repeatable workflows around the client and policy lifecycle.

Current PathwayPort workflows include areas such as:

Renewals
Quote follow-ups
Billing reminders
Welcome communication
Cross-sell campaigns
Referrals
Online reviews
NPS® surveys
Claims communication
Lost-client workflows

PathwayPort also works with insurance management systems so policy and client information can be used to support automated workflows rather than relying only on manually maintained campaign lists.

The objective is not to automate every client interaction. It is to reduce the repetitive administrative work surrounding those interactions.

That can have a significant operational impact.

In one published PathwayPort customer case, the brokerage reported saving 364 hours per month, more than $100,000 in annual cost reductions, and a 70% decrease in renewal workload after introducing automation and two-way integration. The result gives employees more time for the activities technology should not replace:

Advice. Relationships. Complex conversations. Growth.

Frequently Asked Questions About Insurance Automation Strategy

What is an insurance automation strategy?

An insurance automation strategy is a plan for deciding which repetitive insurance processes should be automated, how those workflows connect with existing systems, when employees should intervene and how results will be measured.

What should an insurance agency automate first?

Start with high-volume, repetitive and time-sensitive workflows supported by reliable data. Renewals, quote follow-ups and billing reminders are often strong first candidates.

What should an insurance brokerage automate first?

Brokerages should identify the processes creating the most repetitive administrative work. For many brokerages, this includes renewal preparation and follow-up, payment chasing, routine client communication and information collection.

How do you decide which insurance process to automate?

Evaluate the process based on frequency, manual effort, time sensitivity, data readiness and business impact. Then determine how much professional judgement is required. High-frequency processes with clear rules and reliable data usually offer the strongest starting point.

Should an insurance agency implement AI or automation first?

Start with the business process. Define which steps follow clear rules and which require analysis or judgement. Automation is generally better for predictable actions, while AI can support tasks involving analysis, summarisation or classification.

Can insurance renewals be automated?

Many administrative stages can be automated, including identifying upcoming renewals, requesting information, sending reminders, creating employee activities and maintaining structured communication. Advice and complex coverage decisions should remain human-led.

Can insurance automation replace an AMS or BMS?

It does not need to. Insurance automation can work alongside an existing AMS or BMS and use policy and client information to trigger workflows.

What is the difference between insurance automation and insurance workflow automation?

Insurance automation is the broader use of technology to reduce manual insurance processes. Insurance workflow automation focuses specifically on connecting multiple steps, triggers, actions and exceptions into a repeatable process.

How should insurance agencies measure automation ROI?

Measure the outcome associated with the original problem. Common metrics include administrative hours saved, manual activities reduced, response rates, quote conversion, renewal completion, client engagement and retention.

What insurance tasks should not be fully automated?

Tasks involving professional advice, complex coverage decisions, unusual risks, sensitive complaints and circumstances requiring significant judgement should remain human-led. Automation can support those processes without making the final decision.

Start with the Work, Not the Technology

A strong insurance automation strategy starts with one question:

Where is repetitive work taking time away from client service?

Identify those processes, automate the predictable steps, keep people involved where judgement matters, and measure the results. That is how automation becomes a practical strategy, not just another technology project.

Want to see what to automate first? Book a demo with PathwayPort.

No comments

Collapsible

Insurance Automation Strategy: What Should Agencies and Brokerages Automate First?

Uncategorized

Where to Start with Insurance Automation Insurance agencies and brokerages have more automation options than ever. Renewal reminders can run ...

How to Identify Insurance Renewal Bottlenecks in 5 Steps

Uncategorized

Insurance Renewal Bottlenecks: What's Slowing You Down? Insurance renewal bottlenecks occur when delays, missing information, manual tasks, or unclear responsibilities ...

Policy Cancellation: Does It Mean You’ve Lost a Client?